The Educator's PLN

The personal learning network for educators

Technology in the Classroom- Is it a right? Is it fair?

I am an undergraduate at ISU in my third year studying to be a Special Education teacher. I am currently enrolled in a summer course learning about Assistive Technology. I am a firm supporter of the use of technology in the classroom, but a recent class discussion question got me thinking. Is technology use in the classroom a right? Is it fair? 


Would you go as far as to say that technology use in the classroom is a right for students? Although not legally a right, should it be? Why? Why not?


Is it fair? Many schools do not have the funding to support the use of technology in the classroom. Does that then mean that it is unfair for other schools to implement its use? Why? Why not?


I know that I have mixed opinions when it comes to answering these questions and I am eager to hear what other people have to say regarding this topic.




Views: 75

Replies to This Discussion



First, I wonder if the idea of funding is changing somewhat.  In Indiana, schools now have the opportunity to take funding that originally would have gone for textbooks and use it on alternative curriculum, including the purchase of hardware and software.  To that end, my district is providing an iPad to each incoming freshman and sophomore student next fall.  (We'll increase that by one grade each year until each student leases an iPad each year. )  So, we have the ability to provide technology to students.


On the other hand, it may not be that simple as with other districts in other states, or even other districts in Indiana.  We see that anyway with districts that are barely scraping by financially, while other districts are building new schools, hiring new staff, and so on. 


Personally, I'd say it's completely fair for a district to acquire and implement technology assets if they have the funding available to do so.  If a district doesn't, maybe there are steps they can take (grant writing, for example) to generate funding.  I don't think we want to be in a situation where we hold students in one district back simply because other students in other districts automatically don't have hte same opportunities.


On the other hand, if we demand educational equality, then I'd say it's the obligation of the Federal Government to step in and provide for that.  State governments are already cash-strapped, and to expect every student to have access to the same technology, etc. would probably only be possible on the state level.


Michael Hutchison


Hi Lacey,


I had to struggle with a similar issue on one of my Grad Dip Ed courses.  It became apparent that  equality and fairness are both multi-faceted.  For example, we can give everyone the same tool (e.g. laptop) to cover equal access but is it equal opportunity - perhaps not when some students may require a different laptop as may be the case for assistive tech.  In this sense, it is unfair to give exactly the same tool to every student.


I have also heard of cases where differences in tools (e.g. mobile phones) have led to bullying and this has been used as an argument for banning phones in the classroom. Is that fair?


Teaching and learning is risk-y business.  I think the only way forward with regards to your question is to ask whether or not technology ultimately promotes learning or detracts from it.  If there is a way to mitigate the 'unfairness' and 'inequality' then you'll probably find that technology will enhance teaching and learning.


I hope this helps.





Thomas Whitby created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

Rachael Pawlik posted a status
6 hours ago
Marguerite T. Brode posted a blog post

How to choose profession?

At some point or another, each individual needs to pick or change profession. In youth it is anything but easy to be mixed up, and the committed error can be uneasy to remedy. Above all else, it merits figuring out what put in life you dole out proficient action right now and how this circumstance can change throughout the years. In current conditions there isn’t just an enormous selection of claims to fame.The basics of choosing profession are laid back at school, when the exercises uncover…See More
17 hours ago
Jeffrey R. Ellis posted a blog post

How employment is related to your coursework examples

When fresh out of college, chances are you have little to no work experience, which means your resume may look incomplete to some extent. To make it worse, questions like "what is your past work experience?" seems to be a common pertinent step in all job interviews. Although you may have…See More
Louise Grady updated their profile
Shanshan Ma posted a discussion

Personalized learning network and social media

Hi All, My name is Shanshan Ma, I'm currently a doctoral student at University of North Texas. Nice to meet you all. This platform looks great, many future events could be found. Thanks for sharing. But a questions crossed my mind, how would you see the impact of social media such as Facebook, Twitter on those personal learning networks? Would you believe that members would actively participant in some discussions on social media other than the discussions here??See More
Shanshan Ma liked Ruth Herman Wells's event Portland, OR: Strategies to Teach and Counsel Troubled and Struggling Youth
Lisa Wayne updated their profile
Sep 14
Dennis Dunn updated their profile
Sep 14

Awards And Nominations

© 2018   Created by Thomas Whitby.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service