The Educator's PLN

The personal learning network for educators

I'd like to make something clear regarding my recent post on Waiting for Superman -- please don't read my post thinking that I'm necessarily drinking all of the Kool-Aid. I have questions and doubts just like
anybody else. I don't believe that charters and KIPP and Geoffrey Canada
are the end all be all, if you will. I'm a public school teacher who
believes very strongly that we need to fix our system and I believe that
teachers in the public schools are doing a tremendous job, day in and
day out. But I also believe that we need to accept our responsibility as

I've received a couple emails since my post which have been critical of the stance that I've taken concerning the dismissal of bad teachers. I'd like to clarify my position, just to make sure that it's completely
understood. I believe that once a struggling teacher has been identified
(and I believe this is done through observations, not simply the result
of test scores), he deserves all the help a district has to correct the
problems. I believe that should this teacher not make the necessary
improvements -- and the commitment necessary for our profession -- then
the employer should be permitted to work to remove him. I don't believe
that this teacher should be able to hide behind tenure whatsoever, but I
do believe in due process. For some reason, this was misunderstood in
my last post.

In addition, I am a supporter of our unions; I grew up in a union household and was taught their value early on. I am also a building representative and have had the opportunity to work alongside men and
women who tirelessly work to make our working conditions better. Their
job is underappreciated and there are times I wonder why they put
themselves through the trouble. Selflessly, there are people working in
our unions every single day to help us in the classroom. I will never
believe that a failing teacher who refuses to work to get better and
show improvement, however, should be retained just because of having
taught for two to three years.

Our clientele is simply too precious to allow this to happen. There are Daisy's and Bianca's and Anthony's and Emily's and Francisco's in each and every school in our country. We must strive to make sure that
each one of our clients isn't forced to enter a high stakes lottery by necessity - but the choice should still be there.

There's not a doubt in my mind that I will be referring to this film in future posts -- if nothing else, the film has affected me in this manner -- we need to address these issues, and if it serves as a
rallying cry for the incredible professionals in our industry, then so
be it.

This post may be found at:

Views: 104


You need to be a member of The Educator's PLN to add comments!

Join The Educator's PLN

Comment by Nathan Grimm on October 29, 2010 at 12:42pm
I totally appreciate where you are coming from. I think your views on the way underperforming teachers should be handled is very reasonable. Our education writer for My Dog Ate My Blog just did a piece on KIPP schools from her personal experiences, I would love to hear what you think.


Thomas Whitby created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

John Braswell posted a blog post

What is Your Essay Definition, Explain by Essay Writer?

Essay Definition can vary widely depending on the Person DefiningEssay definition can be different depending on the source. The narrowest definition of essay is “a short piece of writing on a particular subject”, as appearing in Oxford Dictionary. Most common form of essay is written in prose. In practice, essays are regarded as short pieces of writing, though there are some exceptions like John Locke’s” An essay concerning human understanding”. In its broadest sense, definition of essay…See More
Dec 9, 2020
Agnes Mckenna updated their profile
Dec 2, 2020
Eleonore Cowan updated their profile
Dec 2, 2020
Miles Brandon updated their profile
Dec 1, 2020
mario barker updated their profile
Nov 30, 2020
cal bates updated their profile
Nov 30, 2020
jimmy zack updated their profile
Nov 29, 2020
Erick Goodman updated their profile
Nov 27, 2020


© 2021   Created by Thomas Whitby.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service