The Educator's PLN

The personal learning network for educators

Patient Problem Solvers – Ted Talk with Dan Meyers

Let’s face it – not everything that students need to learn in school is easy for them. But wait. If this is knowledge and skills what we want our students to learn, remember, and use in the future (the reason for universal K-12 education right?) then shouldn’t we be teaching them in a way that is intuitive, useful, and easy to remember and use. 

Man Meyers has a great video on Ted Talks called “Math class needs a make-over”. I would like to extend and expand this to all subjects and say that our education system really needs to be remodeled to fit our information age learners (Books and books could be written on that, but let’s stick to this slice of it for now).

Some of the stuff that is hard to teach are things our students need for life. They will continue to not retain it if we do not change the way we teach it. Do you remember any high school science or math. One phrase I go back to is “When you bring the multiplied number to the other side it becomes a division”….Sorry it what? It magically turns into a division?! It wasn’t until University math that it actually clicked why I would divide. It wasn’t magic – it didn’t “turn into” a division.

A simple example of this would be 4×3=12 and 4=12/3 . Knowing the rule is just muscle memory. Understanding the rules is creating logical arguments to explain basic intuition.

Dan explains 5 symptoms you are doing math reasoning wrong, and I believe that steps 1 to 3 apply to any class (history, geography…) and 4 -5 for any science or math class.

1) lack of initiative
2) lack of perseverance
3) lack of retention
4) Aversion to word problems
5) eagerness for formula

It is all about the presentation of the question that makes the difference between students feeling lost and feeling involved. If you present a 4 step textbook question guiding students through the steps there are 3 problems that I see :

1) you are taking away any room for creative discussion or thought and therefore taking away the students need to really think of the whys and hows of the question.

2) you are scaring students who are intimidated by complex questions with lots of words (Dan states that 99% of his students have an aversion to word problems).

3) you are congratulating students for following steps instead of congratulating them on their thinking skills.

An interesting connection Dan makes is to director of the TV show “Deadwood”, David Milch. David has sworn off creating contemporary dramas such as “2 and a half men”. His reason was that it shapes our neural pathways to expect simple solutions for life’s problems – solutions that can be wrapped up in 22 minutes. He describes it as an impatience with irresolution, and that is something we do not want with our students. Instead we want to be creating a exploratory process that end with a resolution that is not limited to one or two classes. It may end with ideas, research, an experiment, or an equation created by the class but it shouldn’t end with an answer from the back of the textbook.

So let’s move towards creating patient problem solvers. Let’s take lessons from video games – where students will spend days or months on end to complete missions. Let’s take lessons from social media – where students will contribute, provoke, and learn from shared resources. Let’s give students the shortest possible question and let them develop the conversation around it. Let’s follow Einstein’s advice :

The formulation of a problem is often more essential than its solution, which may be merely a matter of mathematical or experimental skill.

Let’s get our students involved in forming problem and questions. Do you want your students to write an essay about a recent novel study? Teach them what makes a good essay question (researchability, answerable…), and then develop a question as a class. Do you want your students to learn about osmosis? Serve tea in your classroom and explore what happens when the sugar stops dissolving.

Dan provides a few solutions :

1) Use multimedia – there is such an incredible amount of resources available to be used as teaching materials.

2) Encourage student intuition - bring questions down to their most basic level an provide an opportunity for all students to get involved in the conversation.

3) Ask the shortest question you can – give students a chance to go on tangents, question, wonder about possibilities and most importantly – Make mistakes!

4) Let students build the problem – or question. Because true learning happens from understanding the intution.

5) Be less helpful – let students direct the learning. Let students collaborate. Let them find the answers.

Can you expand upon this list? What works in your classroom?

Views: 166


You need to be a member of The Educator's PLN to add comments!

Join The Educator's PLN


Thomas Whitby created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

John Maker commented on Catrin Cooper's blog post Top Ways Computer Games Effect Student Creativity Choices
"Good video! I agree that some video games can be useful. As for me I prefer to play casino games on online services like There are many cool modern games, video slots are my favorite! Highly recommend to try!"
Christy Glore joined Shelly Terrell's group


Join this group to extend the discussion of edchat topics!
Dec 3
John Maker commented on Regina Adams's blog post To let or not to let your children to play gambling games?
"I think gambling for young kids is not a good idea. But in general I think it can be like a normal hobby. I play for fun quite often with paypal casino nz and don't spend many money on this. Now you can play even with $1. Such games are good…"
Dec 2
John Maker commented on Veronica Hunt's blog post 10 Top Essay Writing Tools To Ease Your Students’ Lives
"Hi there! Good post, these tips are really useful! I also can share one website which can help you to save time when you writing essay. It is StudyMoose, here you can find many essay examples. Like example check these military essays…"
Dec 1
John Maker commented on Jennifer Broflowski's blog post Symptoms You Should Never Ignore.
"Good post! I also can say that you should pay attention on your mental health. Almost all our problems are from this..If you suffer from insomnia, depression or stress you should do something with this! As for me I found good decision, it is CBD…"
Nov 23
Julia Galkina updated their profile
Nov 19
John Maker commented on Thomas Whitby's video

Dan Pink on Motivation in Business.

"Great video! I also want to ask question about accounting for business. I read that modern companies prefer to hire remote accountants for tax filing and other work. Is it good variant? I have small business in Singapore and I want to try services…"
Nov 18
Ruth Herman Wells posted an event

Portland OR Teacher Classroom Management Course at Courtyard by Marriott

October 8, 2020 to October 9, 2020
Management problems in the classroom ends here. This Teacher Classroom Management Course delivers hundreds of strategies for students who struggle with motivation, depression, work refusal, violence and more. Visit our website for more information, or via email ( or call toll-free to 1-800-545-5736See More
Nov 13

© 2019   Created by Thomas Whitby.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service