The Educator's PLN

The personal learning network for educators

Student Achievement Linked Teacher Evaluations and the NYTimes


This is my first post here - and I confess that I did not look to see if there were already similar posts.

This weekend I've read both (Sat and Sun) NYTimes pieces on the release of teacher rating data.

Until this weekend I'd been all for linking teacher evaluation to student performance.

To an extent I still am, but the model used, and the current popular value added component will have some unacceptable consequences.

First - the data is old and does not account for any improvement in a teacher's craft.

The data used and released needs to be closer to the school year examined.

Second - the margin of error is entirely too big.  I not offering what would be acceptable, but 53% is definitely not.

Until the margin of error can be brought down, this data is potentially harmful to a teacher's career.

Third - by directly linking a person's job security to the students on their roster, will at the least stifle, and most likely end any team teaching or grouping of students within or among grade levels.  Furthermore, what would happen to students benefiting from the collective wisdom of their teachers - if teachers are no longer collectively working?

What if we applied this value added student achievement model to grade levels, or to a school?  We could then still work collaboratively, and it would encourage it. 

As educators we do need to see what works best and apply it, and we need to keep the best performers in the field. 

This is not that way.


Views: 147


You need to be a member of The Educator's PLN to add comments!

Join The Educator's PLN


Thomas Whitby created this Ning Network.

Latest Activity

John Braswell posted a blog post

What is Your Essay Definition, Explain by Essay Writer?

Essay Definition can vary widely depending on the Person DefiningEssay definition can be different depending on the source. The narrowest definition of essay is “a short piece of writing on a particular subject”, as appearing in Oxford Dictionary. Most common form of essay is written in prose. In practice, essays are regarded as short pieces of writing, though there are some exceptions like John Locke’s” An essay concerning human understanding”. In its broadest sense, definition of essay…See More
Dec 9, 2020
Agnes Mckenna updated their profile
Dec 2, 2020
Eleonore Cowan updated their profile
Dec 2, 2020
Miles Brandon updated their profile
Dec 1, 2020
mario barker updated their profile
Nov 30, 2020
cal bates updated their profile
Nov 30, 2020
jimmy zack updated their profile
Nov 29, 2020
Erick Goodman updated their profile
Nov 27, 2020


© 2021   Created by Thomas Whitby.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service